By the CIPD Assignment Helper team · Updated 26 October 2026
What Does the NHS Trust 5OS01 Brief Ask You to Write?
Ten replies to colleagues' employment law questions, as an adviser in the People Management department of a large UK NHS trust. Each reply is about 390 words, for 3,900 words in total (plus or minus 10%), and must justify every point it makes.
What Is Your Role in the NHS Trust Scenario?
You specialise in advising colleagues on employment law. In the last few days, ten emails have arrived: from a people management officer who thinks regulation wastes her time, a senior manager who wants to cut posts quickly, a nurse manager who wants to regrade two male health care assistants, a pregnant employee weighing up her leave options and more. Each needs a full, justified reply.
The ten emails follow the 10 criteria in the current specification, from AC 1.1 to AC 4.3. Each criterion is marked from 1 to 4, and you need at least 2 on every one to pass.
The brief's marking bands: total marks across the 10 criteria give 0–19 Fail, 20–25 Low Pass, 26–32 Pass and 33–40 High Pass, provided no criterion is failed or referred. CIPD issues a Pass or Fail at unit level.
Working on the manager-guide 5OS01 brief? See the 5OS01 ARL case study example.
Which Criterion Does Each NHS Email Test?
Each email is one criterion. The right-hand column says what the reply must do, not what it should conclude.
| AC | The colleague's question | What the reply must do | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1.1 | Why spend so much time on regulation? | Evaluate the aims and objectives of employment regulation. |
| 2 | 1.2 | Do pre-Brexit ECJ judgments still bind UK courts? | Examine the role of courts and tribunals and the current status of that case law, with an example. |
| 3 | 2.1 | When can a job be restricted to a man or a woman? | Explain occupational requirements and discrimination principles in recruitment, with examples. |
| 4 | 2.2 | Can two male HCAs be moved from A grade to B grade? | Discuss equal pay law, using the fact that 80% of HCAs are women. |
| 5 | 3.1 | Can a change to hours lead to a constructive dismissal claim, and when is a claim out of time? | Discuss varying contracts, constructive dismissal and tribunal time limits. |
| 6 | 3.2 | Can 50 posts be cut quickly by dismissing the poorest performers? | Explain the legal requirements on redundancy, including consultation and selection. |
| 7 | 3.3 | What rights would staff have if two pharmacy operations merge? | Explain TUPE rights for the employees involved. |
| 8 | 4.1 | How should holiday pay be calculated for casual bank staff? | Explain statutory rights in leave and working time for these workers. |
| 9 | 4.2 | Maternity leave or shared parental leave? | Explain how the two differ and what each offers. |
| 10 | 4.3 | Must we agree to home working three days a week? | Explain flexible working rights and how to handle the request. |
Check every figure, threshold and time limit against current GOV.UK and Acas guidance. The Employment Rights Act 2025 changes several rights in stages.
How Should You Build Each 390-Word NHS Advice Email?
Use the same five-part shape for every email: restate the question, state the rule, apply it to the facts, flag the risk and advise what to do next.
| Part | What goes in | Suggested words |
|---|---|---|
| Opening | Restate the question and give the short answer | 40 |
| The rule | The law, with its source: Act, regulation or leading case | 110 |
| Apply it | What the rule means for this colleague's facts | 120 |
| Risk | What could go wrong, such as a claim, a cost or a delay | 60 |
| Advice | What to do next, and when to come back to you | 60 |
| Per email | 390 |
Keeping every email close to 390 words stops any criterion from getting a thin answer. Cite the sources you rely on, following your centre's referencing rules.
Are Your 5OS01 Emails Stopping at the Rule?
Send two of your drafts. A mentor shows where to apply, flag risk and advise. You write all ten.
What Does a Strong 5OS01 Advice Email Paragraph Look Like?
A short sample in the style of Email 6, for a fictional employer with different facts, so it cannot stand in for your answer.
AC 3.2 sample: Gulf Horizon Health (fictional, Dubai, with a clinic in Birmingham)
Thanks for your note about the 12 admin roles at the Birmingham clinic. Because Gulf Horizon Health is proposing fewer than 20 redundancies at one establishment within 90 days, the collective consultation duty does not apply, but each person still needs fair individual consultation. Selecting only on recent performance scores is risky: a tribunal would ask whether the criteria were objective, applied consistently and free of discrimination, for example against someone whose scores dipped during maternity leave. I suggest we agree a scored matrix with two or three criteria, meet each person before any decision and look for suitable alternative roles first. Can we speak on Thursday, before anything is announced?
What Does This Paragraph Do Well?
- Opens by restating the question, so the reader knows the reply is about their case.
- Gives the rule with its threshold, then applies it to the facts.
- Names the legal risk in plain language.
- Ends with clear next steps and an invitation to talk, which suits an email.
- Uses different facts from Email 6 on purpose. The trust's 50 posts raise different duties, which you work out yourself.
This paragraph is about a fictional organisation and exists only to show technique. Copying or rewording it in your own work is plagiarism, and your centre's rules on sources and AI tools apply to everything you submit.
Which NHS Email Mistakes Do Assessors Mark Down?
The brief asks you to justify every point. Unjustified advice is the most common weakness.
How Do You Use This Email Method if You Advise Managers in the UAE?
Keep the case in the UK, borrow your real advice habits and never mix the two legal systems in one email.
Keep the Case in the UK
The trust is a UK employer, so every reply uses UK law, whatever country you work in.
Borrow Your Real Advice Habits
If you answer manager emails in Dubai or Abu Dhabi, use the same clarity: short answer first, reasons next, clear next step.
Separate the Two Systems
UAE leave, notice and termination rules under Federal Decree-Law No. 33 of 2021 differ from UK rules. Do not mix them in one email.
Check Every Limit
Time limits, thresholds and entitlements change. Check each one on GOV.UK or Acas and note the date you checked.
If your centre lets you write about your own employer instead, confirm which country's law it expects before you start. Most centres expect UK law for 5OS01.
What Do Learners Ask About the NHS Trust 5OS01 Example?
Want a Mentor to Check Your NHS Advice Emails?
Send the brief and your drafts. A mentor checks each email against its criterion and the five-part shape, with replies during UAE working hours. You write all ten.